As I’m sure others have pointed out, the only votes that count are the ones that were cast. So let’s stick with the “81% of evangelicals who voted, voted for Trump”. More than voted for the previous lying, draft-dodging, war-mongering, divorced, multiply married, misogynistic, racist, hate-spewing, divisive, anti-children presidents whose lived lives were in constant contradiction of “Christian values”. Trump is all the above, and more so. And he got a larger fraction of the white evangelical vote. Which leads to the conclusion that the above are actually exactly the values of white Christians.
Of course, they are the values only of those who voted; magically, all the rest of White evangelicaldom are the most loving do-gooders the world has ever seen.